Are gratinated potatoes and potatoes au gratin the same thing?
Butter and potatoes: these two culinary elements are practically ubiquitous in their popularity and prestige, and perhaps unrivaled among all kinds of foods.
Butter and potatoes: these two culinary elements are practically ubiquitous in their popularity and prestige, and perhaps unrivaled among all kinds of foods. By combining them, you can create everything from silky mashed potatoes to disco fries (a New Jersey delicacy), but there are two classic preparations that truly highlight the combination of starchy tubers and rich dairy: scalloped potatoes and potatoes au gratin.
Since these dishes have so much in common, it's easy to think of them as interchangeable. But it turns out there are differences, some of which could make all the difference to your guests and other diners. Perhaps the most notable is another much-loved ingredient: cheese. While scalloped potatoes can sometimes be topped with an optional layer of this delicious ingredient, the traditional recipe doesn't include it. Gratin, on the other hand, is a delicious dish that does feature a generous amount of cheese layered throughout.
Another important difference lies in their preparation. In the gratin version, the potatoes are seasoned with a roux made with flour, butter, and milk. In the au gratin version, they are combined with cream, butter, and the cheese mentioned earlier. This not only results in a different texture but also means that the gratin is a gluten-free dish. However, despite the differences and similarities between the two dishes, they share the commonality of being customizable to individual tastes.
Personalize your potatoes
Many of the personal touches you'd give one of these potato dishes would work just as well with the other. For example, when choosing a cheese for your gratin, you can customize it to your liking, opting for classics like Gruyère, Cheddar, or Parmesan, but you can also experiment with goat's cheese, blue cheese, or Brie; all of these work well if you decide to add cheese to your scalloped potatoes.
In both cases, herbs like thyme and parsley, and alliums like garlic and onion, are excellent additions, as is a sprinkle of crunchy breadcrumbs that provides a contrasting texture to the tender, creamy potatoes. A touch of Dijon mustard adds a subtle hint of spice, while a bolder version could include cayenne pepper. There are plenty of easy-to-prepare canned ingredients that can significantly enhance your scalloped potatoes, from mushroom soup to a hearty chili, which would also pair well with the gratin topping. Or, you could take inspiration from tartiflette, another potato and cheese dish, and add diced ham or bacon for an extra boost of protein (which is also a great way to use up leftover meat). Whichever dish you choose or how you personalize it, these two classic creamy, buttery potato dishes are sure to be a hit with everyone.




