21 November 2026 Get the letterSearchSaved
THE APEX GASTRONOMY CHRONICLE
Food The WireThe CounterThe SourceThe Apex Guide The Recipe FileThe IndexThe Bureau
LATEST
The Counter
The tuna and cranberry sandwich that New Yorkers love so much

The tuna and cranberry sandwich that New Yorkers love so much

The Tunaberry sandwich from Court Street Grocers in New York combines tuna salad with cranberry sauce, a sweet and savory mix that has a loyal clientele.

Chicken salad is one of the best classic sandwiches. The creamy mayonnaise and juicy chicken, mixed with crisp celery and slightly spicy green onions, make for an excellent combination. You can always add an ingredient that elevates the dish: fruit. Cranberries, with their chewy, slightly tart texture, or juicy apples bring a complexity that other chicken salad recipes lack.

That's why it's surprising to find a similar, albeit more unusual, combination in New York City. The Tunaberry sandwich at Court Street Grocers features tuna salad with cranberry sauce, horseradish mayonnaise, white onion, and arugula. It's a unique flavor combination that has earned it a loyal clientele and an interesting history.

The sandwich originated in Providence, Rhode Island, where its creator, Dewey Dufresne (father of acclaimed chef Wylie Dufresne), invented it at his sandwich shop, Joe's, according to Grub Street. The future owners of Court Street Grocers, Eric Finkelstein and Matt Ross, first tasted this sweet and savory combination at that same location, by then under new management. Court Street's version likely incorporates some additional ingredients, but it pays homage to those iconic sandwich shops.

Customers consider it a favorite and describe it as "the best tuna sandwich ever" (according to TripAdvisor). The restaurant's menu includes other unique creations, such as the V-roopy, with roasted swede, French's fried onions, arugula, and horseradish mayonnaise, or the Yam & Cheese, with roasted sweet potatoes, pickled beet cream, whipped goat cheese, pickled red onion, arugula, and sumac vinaigrette.

More The Counter