21 November 2026 Get the letterSearchSaved
THE APEX GASTRONOMY CHRONICLE
Food The WireThe CounterThe SourceThe Apex Guide The Recipe FileThe IndexThe Bureau
LATEST
The Wire
Why the toothpick test is misleading when baking brownies

Why the toothpick test is misleading when baking brownies

The toothpick test works for cakes and muffins, but with brownies it's too late, because they continue to cook after coming out of the oven.

Checking if a cake is done can be tricky, as fans of The Great British Baking Show know. The outside might be perfect while the inside is either raw or overbaked. The most sensible method is to carefully insert a toothpick or a thin-bladed knife: if it comes out clean, without any batter clinging to it or soft crumbs, the cake is ready.

With brownies, however, that signal comes too late. According to experts, when the toothpick comes out clean, it's already too late. Like thick steaks and roasts, brownies continue to cook after being removed from the oven, which is why it's best to let them rest. A few extra minutes won't matter in a thick cake, but they do in brownies, where they can make the difference between chewy squares and dry, crumbly, or dense ones with almost inedible edges.

The toothpick test isn't useless, but with brownies, you need to know how to read it. It's not important that the toothpick comes out completely clean; rather, it should leave some moist batter, which provides just the right amount of moisture for them to finish baking outside the oven. The trick is to start checking for doneness a couple of minutes early, using a clean toothpick each time, and look for the spot in the center of the pan where the toothpick comes back without any traces of raw batter. In sticky brownies, look for streaks of batter and some soft crumbs; in cake-like brownies, look for a few crumbs clinging to the pan.

If the toothpick test isn't enough, take the brownies out as soon as cracks appear on the surface and gently wiggle them to check that the center is firm. If they bake unevenly, with hard edges and an undercooked center, there are other solutions: place them on the middle rack instead of the bottom one, or bake them in a water bath, like flan.

More The Wire