Is pho considered a soup or a Vietnamese noodle dish?
The debate over whether pho is a soup pits those who see its bone broth as the defining feature against those who consider it a main dish in its own right.
Pho combines cardamom, ginger, coriander, cloves, cinnamon, and star anise, and its spicy aroma is the first thing that captivates you upon sitting down to eat. It's served with plenty of rice noodles, thinly sliced meat, vegetables like carrots and broccoli, and fresh herbs such as cilantro and basil, all simmered in a lemony bone broth with bean sprouts and spring onions. Sometimes it includes cabbage, snow peas, or sauteed shiitake mushrooms, and the best pho is made with lean cuts of beef, chicken, shrimp, or tofu.
Some argue that the ever-present bone broth makes it a soup, and that any added ingredient transforms it into a noodle soup. Others counter that classifying it as a soup relegates it to an appetizer or side dish, when pho is a main course and the foundation of a meal. Its proponents point out that the combination of complex broth, protein, and fresh garnish places it in a category of its own, though many still consider it a soup.
The broth is the heart of the matter. It should be relatively clear and very aromatic, with several layers of flavor, and is obtained by simmering the bones. The usual ingredients are yellow onion, ginger, star anise, cloves, cinnamon, salt, fish sauce, yellow rock sugar, and beef bones with marrow, sometimes with beef knuckle bones and a little more meat.
Everything is simmered for a minimum of three hours, although many recipes suggest six or more. Restaurant-quality pho may be simmered for 12 hours or more to achieve exceptional depth of flavor.
No two batches of pho are the same, and each cook usually has their own style that keeps customers coming back. Essentially, it's a home-style dish that evolves with each person who adds ingredients.
Pho is Vietnam's national dish, but its origins are shrouded in mystery. It likely originated in Hanoi, influenced by Chinese, French, and local cuisines. When the French took control of Nam Dinh province in the Red River Delta, culinary styles merged. It was probably first served as street food along the Red River in the north of the country.
The blend of influences is reminiscent of simmering broth, which requires hours, sometimes even days, for the marrow to dissolve. Using pre-made chicken or beef broth yields a simpler pho in about 30 minutes, with a less complex but equally rich flavor.




