The myth of the marinade that doesn't tenderize meat
Marinades add flavor, but, according to science, they are not the solution for tenderizing cheaper cuts of meat.
There are countless recipes for marinating meats, with spicy, sweet and sour, or sweet flavors like honey and brown sugar. Many grilling recipes recommend marinating meat, poultry, and even fish. Marinades have their uses in cooking, but they aren't the best solution for the most economical cuts of meat.
The basis of a marinade is a combination of oil, acid, and seasonings such as salt, herbs, and spices. According to Discover magazine, salt alters the balance of liquids between the marinade and the meat: some of the liquid is drawn out of the meat, mixes with the flavors, and is partially reabsorbed by osmosis. Oil helps fat-soluble flavors, such as thyme, rosemary, or sage, penetrate the meat, according to Cook's Illustrated.
The acid serves a purpose, but that's precisely where the myth lies. Meat is muscle, made up of proteins, water, carbohydrates, fats, and connective tissue fibers like collagen and elastin, according to the Exploratorium. It's these fibers, abundant in inexpensive cuts like brisket and flank, that toughen the meat.
Cook's Illustrated states that acids denature proteins, meaning they unfold them, but they cannot penetrate the density of the meat to tenderize it completely. If meat is left to marinate for too long, the outer layer becomes mushy and unappealing.
According to The Washington Post, the best way to tenderize meat is through cooking. Braising, stewing, and simmering break down collagen into gelatin, which gives a smooth, silky texture and thickens the juices. Slicing the meat before marinating, according to Cook's Illustrated, allows the marinade to penetrate more deeply and impart more flavor.
Meat injected with marinade or brine will tenderize, but it must be cooked to a safe internal temperature because bacteria on the surface can penetrate the meat, according to the USDA. The same is true for meat pierced with needles. Ultimately, the secret to tender meat lies in cooking, not marinating.




