A simple tip from Ina Garten for more precise baking
Ina Garten recommends avoiding self-raising flour because it does not allow for control of the rising process, which is key to precise baking.
Garten defends this advice in an episode of "Barefoot Contessa" on the Food Network, while preparing her double chocolate cake recipe. "You don't want a cake that's too light or too dense. Just perfect," she commented.
With self-raising flour, the baker controls the leavening agents. Self-raising flours already contain leavening ingredients, which can lead to uneven baking, a problem with an important birthday cake. Adding extra leavening agents to these flours is also undesirable, as the results would be even more inconsistent.
It's not always necessary to avoid it. Some recipes, like beer bread or quick breads like banana bread, use self-raising flour. But if the recipe calls for specific amounts of baking soda or baking powder, it's not advisable to substitute regular flour.
Cookies and cakes require different proportions of raising agents. Some recipes, like shortbread or pie crusts, don't call for raising agents and wouldn't work with self-rising flour; in those cases, all-purpose flour is the best option.




