How to make sweets without a thermometer using the cold water test
Making candy without a thermometer is possible, because confectioners of the past used the cold water test, which is just as reliable for tracking the stages of sugar.
Making candy without a thermometer isn't impossible. While a candy thermometer makes it easier to achieve perfect caramelization by providing precise temperatures, the cold water test is just as reliable and was used before thermometers were invented.
The test involves dropping the hot syrup into ice water, where it cools rapidly, allowing the tester to determine its stage of hardness. As it heats up, the sugar syrup goes through seven stages of hardness, each suitable for making different types of sweets.
The test is repeated several times while the sugar is heated, so it's advisable to prepare an ice bath beforehand. For more accurate results, ice is not placed directly into the water used for the test: a small container of cold water is placed inside a larger container filled with ice, so that the sugar does not come into direct contact with the ice.
As it cooks, the sugar molecules break down and rearrange into new structures, which become evident upon cooling. Every three to five minutes, a small amount of syrup is dropped into the cold water bath with a spoon to check its stage of development.
In the thread stage, from 223 to 235 degrees Fahrenheit, thin, flexible threads form, perfect for candying bacon or fruit. In the soft ball stage, from 235 to 245 degrees Fahrenheit, a ball forms that deflates quickly. In the firm ball stage, from 245 to 250 degrees Fahrenheit, the ball doesn't deflate but is easily flattened between the fingers. In the hard ball stage, from 250 to 266 degrees Fahrenheit, it gives slightly but retains its shape.
The soft crack stage, from 270 to 290 degrees Fahrenheit, and the hard crack stage, from 300 to 310 degrees Fahrenheit, form thick, strong strands that hold together. In the hard crack stage, the strands become hard and brittle, prone to cracking. The final stage is the caramel stage, between 160 and 175 degrees Celsius, in which the sugar acquires an amber-brown color and a rich, buttery aroma, perfect for homemade ice cream.




