21 November 2026 Get the letterSearchSaved
THE APEX GASTRONOMY CHRONICLE
Food The WireThe CounterThe SourceThe Apex Guide The Recipe FileThe IndexThe Bureau
LATEST
The Counter
Holdfast, a seafood counter in Allston with lobster rolls, caviar, and crudo

Holdfast, a seafood counter in Allston with lobster rolls, caviar, and crudo

Chefs Nathan Gould and Tyler Paolini, formerly of O Ya omakase, are opening a seafood counter in Allston that combines refined flavors with a casual atmosphere.

Here you can order lobster rolls with fries, or caviar and raw fish, and eat at a communal table or grab a quick bite at the bar. The restaurant is open from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, Tuesday through Saturday, and serves lunch, dinner, or a night out.

The lobster rolls, priced according to market rates, are available in two versions: a hot one smothered in lobster bisque butter with a hint of lime, or a cold one with a salad described as "lobster bisque style." Those wishing to settle the age-old New England debate can order both and share.

No meal here is complete without fries ($5) with the house-made, slightly tangy Otter sauce. There are three kinds: sea salt, salt and vinegar, and crab seasoning. For something more sophisticated, the raw jack mackerel ($14) is served with smoked olive oil, grapefruit ponzu, nori seaweed, and shiso.

For now, Holdfast is in the process of obtaining its license to sell beer and wine, and only serves soft drinks. Soon, customers will be able to order a local beer or a glass of white wine to accompany their lobster rolls.

The restaurant only has 20 seats, so be prepared to share a table with strangers or eat standing at the bar. When the weather is nice, you can order a wrap to go and enjoy a sophisticated picnic.

Key facts
  • Who: Holdfast Specialty Seafood Co · Allston · Nathan Gould · Tyler Paolini
  • Money: $5 · $14

More The Counter