02 October 2026 · Vol. XXXIV · № 12.327 Get the letterSearchSaved
THE APEX GASTRONOMY CHRONICLE
Food The Exchange & The CounterThe Wire The IndexThe Bureau
LATEST
The Wire
Get the Lobster Rolls, Caviar, and Crudo at This New Allston Seafood Counter

Get the Lobster Rolls, Caviar, and Crudo at This New Allston Seafood Counter

Holdfast Specialty Seafood Co., the newly-minted Allston seafood shop from local chefs Nathan Gould and Tyler Paolini (formerly of O Ya omakase), blends refined flavors with casual ambiance. Order lobster rolls and fries or caviar and crudo, then dig in at a communal table or enjoy quick eats at counter seating.

What to order

  • Settle the eternal New England debate by ordering a hot lobster roll (market price) doused in lobster bisque butter with a spritz of lime or a cold lobster roll with a salad described as “lobster bisque-style.” If you’re feeling flush, order both and split with a friend, but they are market price.
  • No meal here is complete without a side of fries ($5) in the tangy, house-made Otter sauce. Choose between three types of fries: sea salt, salt and vinegar, and crab seasoning.
  • For something that feels fancier, try the yellowtail crudo ($14) served with smoked olive oil, grapefruit ponzu, nori, and shiso.

Take note

For now, Holdfast was in the process of obtaining a beer and wine license. For now, it’s only soft drinks. Soon, diners should be able to order a local brew or a glass of white with lobster rolls.

Insider tip

There are only 20 seats in this tiny restaurant, so be prepared to split a table with strangers or stand at a counter and munch. In the warmer weather, consider grabbing a lobster roll to go for a bougie picnic.

Key facts
  • Who: Holdfast Specialty Seafood Co · Allston · Nathan Gould · Tyler Paolini
  • Money: $5 · $14

More The Wire