21 November 2026 Get the letterSearchSaved
THE APEX GASTRONOMY CHRONICLE
Food The WireThe CounterThe SourceThe Apex Guide The Recipe FileThe IndexThe Bureau
LATEST
The Counter
When to avoid ordering desserts at restaurants

When to avoid ordering desserts at restaurants

When you dine out as often as we do, both personally and professionally, you also learn a thing or two about dining. We've thoroughly studied what to look for when reading restaurant reviews, pinpointed which dishes are best avoided, and memorized the crucial differences between a filet mignon and a chateaubriand.

Often, if a restaurant's desserts are purchased from outside suppliers rather than made in-house, they're more likely to be a combination of frozen, outdated, and low-quality products, at the customer's expense. Nobody wants to pay an exorbitant price for a piece of Pepperidge Farm sponge barely disguised with a sprig of mint. You want something freshly baked like a cake, whipped like a mousse, or at least dipped in chocolate, like a classic and romantic strawberry, to savor its sweetness. That way, you know you're investing your time and money in something special that you won't find just anywhere. However, there are some exceptions to this rule.

Rules, like crème brûlée, are made to be broken.

Some renowned restaurants incorporate more care into their dessert menus than others. They may lack the space, equipment, or staff to make their own sweets, so they source them from other suppliers. They may even obtain them from their own partner establishments. For example, Minetta Tavern in New York City delivers its coconut cake daily from its own bakery, Balthazar Bakery. Balthazar also distributes to other restaurants in the city, an advantage these establishments often highlight, given the bakery's popularity.

Other times, restaurants might serve mass-produced sweets as a joke. Maybe they'll give a Twinkie googly eyes, add an expensive ingredient to the Jell-O, or play around with fizzy candies. As long as everyone is transparent about where the products come from, there's nothing wrong with a little culinary nostalgia. But you can probably get them cheaper on your way home.

More The Counter